Why is everyone looking at P/E ratios when evaluating stocks? Is P/B actually better for Indian markets?

Published 28 September 2026

Vibhor from Mumbai
I have been investing directly in stocks for about 2 years.

I always screen for low P/E stocks because that is what most blogs suggest.

But during market crashes the P/E ratios seem to go crazy and do not make sense.

I have about Rs 15 Lakhs in direct equities right now.

Should I be looking at Price-to-Book instead and how do I even use P/B to find good entry points?
Sachin Kabra Sachin Kabra ex-Director HDFC Private Wealth, Business Head Motilal Oswal AMC LinkedIn
Price-to-Book is a much more stable way to value a business compared to the commonly cited P/E ratio. Earnings can be highly volatile but a company's net worth rarely fluctuates dramatically from year to year. The most important variable to understand in equity investing is Return on Equity or ROE.

If a business generates a 15% return on its invested capital it is creating extra value over the risk-free rate. As a rule of thumb a business generating a 15% ROE generally commands a valuation of about three times its capital. Historically over the last 45 years the median ROE of the Sensex has been around 15% and the market's average valuation has hovered around 3 to 3.2 times Price-to-Book.

During a crash like COVID stock prices plummeted but corporate earnings evaporated even faster. As a result P/E ratios still looked artificially high and masked the fact that stocks were actually cheap. Conversely the market's P/B ratio had dropped to roughly 2x during that time.

Historically whenever the Indian market's P/B falls to 2x it signals a fantastic buying opportunity.

Disclaimer: All information shared above are strictly for educational and informational purposes only. It should not be construed as financial or investment advice.
Ask Sachin

Get your question answered by our advisor.

More from Sachin Kabra

Kumaran from Surat
I work in IT and want to buy a Rs 1.5 Cr flat in Bengaluru. Is my job safe enough for a 15-year EMI?

I am 32 and working as a mid-level engineer in a top IT firm in Bengaluru. I am planning to buy an apartment worth about Rs 1.5cr. My current salary can easily cover the EMI and I…

Read More »
Inder from Hyderabad
First time seeing a market correction: How do I handle a 15% drop in my mutual fund portfolio?

I started investing about three years ago and have only seen a massive bull run. Recently my equity portfolio dropped by about 15% and I am getting very anxious. I have about Rs 12…

Read More »
Jagjit from Bhubaneswar
Should I buy a Rs 1.5 Cr flat on loan or keep renting at Rs 40K a month?

I am 35 and currently renting a nice apartment for Rs 40K a month. My family is pushing me to buy a house which would cost around Rs 1.5cr. The EMI would be massive compared to my…

Read More »
Sparsh from Delhi
Planning to FIRE at 45 with Rs 1.2 Lakhs monthly expense: Is a Rs 4 Cr corpus enough?

I am 38 and planning to retire by 45. My current monthly expenses are about Rs 1.2 Lakhs. I want to know if a corpus of Rs 4 Crores will be enough to sustain me. I plan to travel m…

Read More »
Srujana from Pune
I always end up selling my winning stocks too early. How do you hold on for 10x or 100x returns?

I have a terrible habit of booking profits the moment a stock doubles or triples. I bought a few smallcap pharma and finance stocks a few years ago. I sold them when I made a 100%…

Read More »