How do I compare two mutual funds with the exact same past returns?

Published 30 September 2026

Punit from Gurugram avatar Punit from Gurugram
I am looking at two flexi-cap funds for a 10yr horizon.

Both show around 17% annualized returns over the last 3yr.

How do I decide which one is actually better? Should I just flip a coin or is there a metric I am missing?
Sachin Kabra Sachin Kabra Co-founder Foliyo (SEBI RIA No: INA000023454), ex-Director HDFC Private Wealth, Business Head Motilal Oswal AMC LinkedIn
You need to look at how much risk each fund manager took to get you that 17% return by checking their standard deviation and Sharpe ratio. Looking at past returns is like looking at the final destination of a journey without asking how bumpy the ride was.

Think of it like taking a bike trip to Ladakh. You have two route options to get there. Option A is a smooth and scenic highway.

Option B is a broken and accident-prone dirt road with extreme elevation changes. Both routes get you to Ladakh at the exact same time. But Option B is highly volatile and far less enjoyable.

In mutual fund terms, if a fund achieves high returns but takes on extreme volatility to get there, it is taking on excessive risk. This is where a metric called the Sharpe ratio comes in. It measures the extra reward you get for the extra risk the fund took compared to a safe government bond.

Imagine your two funds have nearly identical 3yr annualized returns of around 17%. But Fund A has a Sharpe ratio of 0.62 and Fund B has a Sharpe ratio of 0.73. The higher the Sharpe ratio, the better the fund manager is at handling volatility.

Fund B is the superior choice here because it managed its risk much better to achieve the exact same level of returns. You can also check the standard deviation. If a fund has a 3yr return of 17% and a standard deviation of 15%, you can expect the returns to fluctuate by plus or minus 15% going forward.

Always compare these metrics against direct peers. Compare your flexi-cap fund against other flexi-cap funds to see which one offers the smoothest ride to your financial goals.

Disclaimer: All information shared above are strictly for educational and informational purposes only. It should not be construed as financial or investment advice.
Ask Sachin

Get your question answered by our partner advisors.

Related guides

More from Sachin Kabra