Investing Lumpsum: One go vs SIP
Choose a start date, total amount and number of monthly instalments. The calculator invests the first SIP on the lumpsum date, then invests the remaining instalments on the same day of each following month.
For the full guide to deploying a windfall (how long to stagger, the immediate-plus-STP split and the tax angles by source of money), see Deploying a Lump Sum into Mutual Funds.
Set up your comparison
How your investments grow
The chart tracks both strategies at monthly valuation points through the final valuation date.
| Date | Invested | Lumpsum value | SIP value |
|---|
Methodology: NIFTY 50 TRI closing values from historical index dataset. The first SIP is invested on the effective start date; each later SIP uses the same day of month, shifted to the next available trading day when needed. Results exclude taxes, fees, tracking error and returns on uninvested cash. This is a historical illustration, not a forecast.
Data coverage: 1 January 2015 to 30 April 2026 ยท Index: NIFTY 50 TRI
Worked example
Say you had โน20 lakh on 2 May 2019 (the calculator's default). Invested in one go in the NIFTY 50 TRI, it was worth โน40,94,293 on 2 May 2024, a 104.71% absolute return. Split into five monthly SIPs of โน4 lakh, from 2 May to 3 September 2019, it was worth โน41,63,865, a 108.19% return. The SIP finished ahead here because the index fell from June to September 2019, so the later instalments bought at lower levels.
Start on 23 March 2020 instead, near the bottom of the Covid fall, with six instalments, and the result flips: by 21 March 2025 the lumpsum had grown to โน64,98,780 and the SIP to โน51,13,361, because every later instalment bought at a higher level. Which approach wins depends on what the market does in the months you are spreading the money over, which nobody knows in advance.
Frequently asked questions
What does this simulator compare?
It takes one amount and invests it two ways in the NIFTY 50 TRI: all at once on the start date (lumpsum), or in equal monthly instalments starting on that date (SIP). Both are valued on the same later date, so the only difference is when the money went in.
Is a lumpsum better than an SIP for a windfall?
In this dataset it usually ended ahead, but not always. Across the 1,566 start dates from January 2015 that have five years of data after them, investing at once beat a six-month SIP 65% of the time, and the median gap was 2.8%. The other 35% of the time, mostly when the market fell soon after the start, the SIP did better. Spreading the money out costs a little on average and protects you from investing everything just before a fall.
How many SIP instalments should I use?
Most people who stagger a windfall into equity funds spread it over 3 to 12 months. The more instalments, the longer part of the money waits outside the market, so in this data a 12-month SIP trailed a lumpsum more often (72% of start dates) than a 6-month one. The right split depends on how much of a fall soon after investing you could live with; our guide to deploying a lump sum covers it.
Why the NIFTY 50 TRI and not a mutual fund?
The total return index (TRI) includes dividends reinvested, so it shows what the market itself returned. A real index fund would earn slightly less because of its expense ratio and tracking error, and an active fund could do better or worse.
Does the result include taxes, fees or interest on the waiting cash?
No. The results leave out taxes, fees and tracking error, and the money waiting for later SIP instalments earns nothing here. In practice you might park it in a liquid fund and move it with an STP, which would narrow the SIP's gap a little.
Does this tell me what will happen next?
No. It replays what the NIFTY 50 TRI did between 2015 and 2026. Past returns are not a guide to future returns, and this is an illustration, not investment advice.