Investing Rs 10K a month for 20 years: Does a 0.5% higher expense ratio in active funds really matter?

Published 29 September 2026

Raja from Chennai
I am 28 and planning to start a Rs 10K monthly SIP for the next 20 years.

I am confused between a popular active large-cap fund and a simple Nifty 50 index fund.

The active fund has an expense ratio of around 1% while the index fund is at 0.2%.

People say active funds beat the index but does that small fee difference actually eat into my returns over two decades?
Sachin Kabra Sachin Kabra ex-Director HDFC Private Wealth, Business Head Motilal Oswal AMC LinkedIn
The total expense ratio or TER is not just a minor fee but a massive drag on your long-term wealth. When you invest in a mutual fund the fee is not billed to you separately but is subtracted directly from the NAV every single day. Over a 20-year period this daily deduction compounds heavily against you.

If you invest Rs 10K every month in an index fund and someone else invests the exact same amount in an active fund for 20 years straight a mere 0.5% difference in the expense ratio results in a massive Rs 3.9 Lakhs difference in the final corpus. Cost advantage is the primary reason to choose index funds over actively managed ones.

The sole job of an index fund is to replicate its underlying index like the Nifty 50. However this replication process is never perfect and the gap between the index's actual return and the fund's return is called the tracking difference.

This difference occurs due to cash drag where funds keep cash on hand for daily redemptions and rebalancing costs when the underlying index changes. There are also dividend reinvestment delays because fund operations take time to receive the money and reinvest it. Over a 10 or 20-year period this tracking difference compounds just like the expense ratio.

You should always check the scheme document on platforms like Zerodha Coin and choose a fund with the lowest possible tracking difference.

Disclaimer: All information shared above are strictly for educational and informational purposes only. It should not be construed as financial or investment advice.
Ask Sachin

Get your question answered by our advisor.

More from Sachin Kabra

Naga from Ludhiana
How are SIFs taxed compared to a PMS? Is the tax deferral really a big advantage?

I am comparing a Rs 50L investment in a PMS versus spreading that money across a few SIFs. My CA mentioned something about tax drag in a PMS because every trade is taxed. Do SIFs o…

Read More »
Aniket from Delhi
Are SIFs just risky hedge funds? How do they protect against market crashes?

I am looking at adding a Hybrid Long-Short SIF to my portfolio. The fund manager says they use derivatives and short selling to protect against market falls. I have always been tol…

Read More »
Rohan from Delhi
My portfolio just crossed Rs 1.8 Cr. Should I move Rs 50L to a PMS or try these new SIFs?

I am 42 and have been investing in regular equity MFs for 15 years. My total mutual fund corpus recently hit about Rs 1.8cr. I am looking for something more sophisticated to protec…

Read More »
Sujith from Pune
Should I allocate 10% of my Rs 80L portfolio to Gold? Does it actually hedge against Rupee depreciation?

I have around Rs 80L invested across Nifty index funds and some FDs. I keep reading about global uncertainties, central banks buying gold, and the Rupee slowly losing value against…

Read More »
Siju from Hyderabad
Confused between overvalued growth stocks and cheap value traps. How do you pick stocks in this market?

I am 34 and currently investing about Rs 50K via SIPs every month. Every time I look at high-growth companies, their valuations seem completely disconnected from fundamentals. But…

Read More »