How the High-Water Mark Fee Model Works in Indian PMS

When investing in Portfolio Management Services (PMS) in India, fee structure has a large impact on final net returns. Unlike public mutual funds, which are restricted to a Total Expense Ratio (TER), PMS providers can charge performance-linked fees.

To protect high-net-worth investors, SEBI has made the High-Water Mark (HWM) model mandatory for all performance-linked fee calculations in India.

If you are looking for a fee-only SEBI Registered Investment Advisor (RIA) to evaluate your PMS agreements and model your net-of-fee returns, Find a Fee Only Investment Advisor.

1. What is the High-Water Mark Model?

The High-Water Mark is a regulatory model for calculating performance fees.

• The Rule: A portfolio manager can only charge a performance fee on new gains that exceed the highest historical value (peak value) that the portfolio has ever achieved.
• The Goal: It ensures that you are never charged a performance fee twice on the same gains, and that the manager must recover previous losses before earning a single rupee of performance fees on new profits.

2. A Real-World Mathematical Example

Let’s trace the fee calculation of a ₹1 Crore portfolio over a three-year period under a 20% performance fee model with a 10% annual hurdle rate (and zero fixed fee for simplicity):

graph TD
    A["Year 1: ₹1.0 Cr Invested"] -->|"Gross 15% Return"| B["Year 1 Peak: ₹1.15 Cr"]
    B -->|"Fixed 1.5% + 20% Perf Fee on Gains > 10%"| C["Year 1 End Net AUM: ₹1.12 Cr"]
    C -->|"Year 2 Market Crash (-20%)"| D["Year 2 End AUM: ₹89.6L"]
    D -->|"Year 3 Recovery (+35%)"| E["Year 3 Gross: ₹1.21 Cr"]
    E -->|"HWM Capped: No Perf Fee on recovery up to ₹1.12 Cr peak"| F["Year 3 Net: High Performance Alpha"]

Year 1: Positive Alpha

• Starting AUM: ₹1,00,000,000 (₹1 Crore).
• Hurdle Value (10%): ₹1,10,000,000.
• Year-End Gross AUM: ₹1,15,000,000 (15% gross return).
• Gain above Hurdle: ₹5,000,000.
• Performance Fee (20%): ₹1,000,000.
• Year-End Net AUM: ₹1,14,000,000.
• New High-Water Mark: ₹1,14,000,000 (this is the new peak the manager must beat).

Year 2: Market Correction

• Starting AUM (HWM): ₹1,14,000,000.
• Year-End AUM: ₹90,000,000 (due to a market correction).
• Performance Fee: ₹0 (no gains generated).
• High-Water Mark Status: The HWM remains fixed at ₹1,14,000,000. The manager must recover the ₹24 Lakhs loss before charging any future performance fees.

Year 3: Recovery and New Gains

• Starting AUM: ₹90,000,000.
• Year-End Gross AUM: ₹1,25,000,000.
• Gross Gain in Year 3: ₹35,000,000.
• High-Water Mark Check: The previous peak (HWM) was ₹1,14,000,000.
• Taxable Performance Gain: Only gains above the HWM (₹1,25,000,000 − ₹1,14,000,000 = ₹11,000,000) are subject to a performance fee.
• Performance Fee (20% on ₹11,000,000): ₹2,200,000.
• Net Year-End AUM: ₹1,22,800,000.
• New High-Water Mark: ₹1,22,800,000.

[!NOTE] Without the High-Water Mark: In Year 3, the manager would have charged a 20% performance fee on the entire ₹35 Lakhs recovery gain from the low point of ₹90 Lakhs, costing you ₹7,00,000. The HWM saved you ₹4,80,000 by ensuring you only paid for net new wealth generated.

3. Fixed vs. Variable Performance Fee Models

HNI investors typically choose between three fee structures in a PMS:

A. Fixed Fee Only

• Fee: Typically 2.0% to 2.5% p.a.
• Best for: Investors who expect high alpha and want to keep 100% of the returns above the fixed cost.

B. Variable/Performance Fee Only

• Fee: 0% fixed fee, 20% to 25% profit share above hurdle (usually 10%).
• Best for: Investors who want stronger incentive alignment. The manager earns no performance fee if the portfolio fails to beat the hurdle.

C. Hybrid Structure

• Fee: Lower fixed fee (e.g., 1.5% p.a.) plus a lower performance fee (e.g., 15% profit share above 10% hurdle).
• Best for: Balancing alignment with cost control.

FAQ

Is the High-Water Mark mandatory in Indian PMS?

Yes. Under SEBI Portfolio Managers Regulations, all performance-linked fees must be calculated on a High-Water Mark basis over a minimum period of one year.

What is a hurdle rate?

A hurdle rate is the minimum return the portfolio manager must generate before they are entitled to charge a performance fee. For example, if the hurdle rate is 10%, the first 10% of returns are completely free of performance fees.

How does cash withdrawal affect the High-Water Mark?

If you make a partial withdrawal from your PMS, the High-Water Mark is adjusted downwards on a pro-rata basis to reflect the capital withdrawn, ensuring the calculations remain fair and mathematically accurate.

Want to evaluate the net-of-fee returns of a prospective PMS contract? Find a Fee Only Investment Advisor →